[Article] From DT 1.0 to DT 3.0: The Strategic Impact of Design Thinking Evolution on Business Decision-Making

By
Administration Team
-
0
244

English | 繁體中文

Table of Contents

Part 1: Background

Part 2: DT 1.0 (Traditional Design Thinking)

Part 3: DT 2.0 (Data-Driven Design Thinking)

Part 4: DT 3.0 (Data-Driven Design Thinking with Artificial Intelligence Tools)

Part 5: Implications for Business Leaders

Background

The evolution of Design Thinking (DT) is transforming executive decision-making by incorporating structured, data-driven methodologies. As organizations confront complex challenges, the integration of advanced technologies like AI into the DT process empowers leaders to make informed, agile decisions that are highly responsive to user needs and dynamic market conditions.

Each evolution from DT 1.0 to DT 3.0 systematically integrates a broader array of technological and analytical tools. This integration, which includes advanced data and AI resources, aligns seamlessly with the traditional model, substantially boosting both the effectiveness and efficiency of the innovation process.

This enhancement extends across various strategic domains, including product innovation, service improvement, business model refinement, process re-engineering, and marketing innovation. Such comprehensive advancements are pivotal for senior executives aiming to drive sustained growth and competitive differentiation in their organizations.

Based on a human-centered approach and an emphasis on qualitative analysis, DT 3.0 achieves significant advancements in predictive, responsive, and user-customized design practices through the comprehensive integration of data-driven and artificial intelligence technologies.

Recent business research indicates that innovation teams using DT 3.0 can reduce project timelines by up to 48%, highlighting its importance in accelerating the innovation process. This breakthrough is of strategic significance for business leaders who need to respond quickly and effectively to market changes.

Therefore, many internationally renowned companies, such as Apple, Airbnb, Amazon, HSBC, and Tesla, have adopted DT 3.0 as their core innovation management tool to enhance innovation efficiency and market responsiveness.

In the structure of corporate innovation projects, it is common to divide the process into six core stages: : Determine Major Changes and Challenges, Discover All-Rounded Information, Define Root Causes and Opportunities, Develop Creative Ideas, Deliver Innovative Solutions, and Drive Changes and Results. Below, we will further elucidate the characteristics and differences in the design thinking approach as it evolves from DT 1.0 to DT 2.0 and DT 3.0.

For the video edition, please click here.

DT 1.0: Traditional Design Thinking

Traditional Design Thinking emphasizes human-centric solutions using qualitative approaches. The major stages in DT 1.0 are:

  1. Determine: This approach relies heavily on the team’s subjective experience and intuition to identify challenges. It prioritizes creative meetings and open discussions to unearth issues, allowing for a broad exploration of potential problems.
  2. Discover: Emphasizes face-to-face interactions and observations with users, relying on human observation and empathy to gather data. This direct engagement ensures that insights are deeply rooted in user experiences and needs.
  3. Define: The team uses its collective understanding and interpretations to formulate problem statements, which are typically qualitative and descriptive. This process helps in clearly articulating the challenges to be addressed.
  4. Develop: This stage leads the generation of innovative solutions through brainstorming sessions and creative workshops. It values creative freedom and unrestricted thinking, fostering an environment where new ideas can flourish.
  5. Deliver: Physical prototypes and user testing drive product iterations in this phase. User feedback refines solutions, ensuring that the final products align with user expectations and requirements.
  6. Drive: Decisions made by the leadership team and key stakeholders propel the implementation of solutions. This stage emphasizes internal communication and momentum within the organization, which is crucial for successful adoption and implementation.

Example (1): In DT 1.0, using a customer journey map (See picture below) involves building empathy through qualitative data. For example, in a retail clothing store, you observe a customer struggling to find the right size. By capturing photos and taking notes on their experience, the map helps you understand their frustrations. This method allows you to witness customer challenges directly, fostering trust and empathy, which leads to improvements in in-store layout and staff interactions.

Source: Samsung Digital Transformation: How to respond smartly to VUCA World

For business leaders overseeing innovation projects, understanding these stages helps in effectively guiding teams through the complex process of design thinking, ensuring that solutions are both innovative and practical.

For the video edition, please click here.

DT 2.0: Data-Driven Design Thinking

Integrating data into the Design Thinking process validates assumptions and enhances decision-making at every stage:

  1. Determine: Data analytics aid in identifying and defining key business challenges. Insights supported by data guide the initial problem identification, ensuring that issues are accurately recognized based on empirical evidence.
  2. Discover: Traditional user research methods, such as surveys and behavioral data analysis, are augmented with data analytics. This integration of quantitative data and qualitative insights provides a more comprehensive understanding of user needs and behaviors.
  3. Define: Specific data points articulate problems clearly. Data-supported evidence ensures the accuracy and relevance of problem statements, grounding them in verifiable metrics.
  4. Develop: Data insights drive the creation of solutions. Predictive analytics and market trend data are utilized to craft innovative solutions that are informed by current and projected contexts.
  5. Deliver: Data metrics enhance rapid prototyping and testing of solutions. This data-driven iteration process allows for adjustments based on actual performance, optimizing the final product’s effectiveness.
  6. Drive: Implementation strategies are supported and adjusted using data analytics. Continuous data tracking and performance evaluation ensure that goals are effectively met and sustained.

Example (2): In DT 2.0, the customer journey map (See picture below) incorporates quantitative data to understand behavioral changes. For instance, in the same clothing store, you collect data on how often customers use fitting rooms and analyze purchase versus return patterns. This map helps identify popular items and optimize inventory, enabling targeted marketing strategies to enhance customer satisfaction and reduce returns.

Source: Samsung Digital Transformation: How to respond smartly to VUCA World

For business leaders, embracing DT 2.0 means leveraging data throughout the innovation cycle to make informed, strategic decisions that are more likely to result in successful outcomes. This approach not only streamlines the development process but also enhances the precision of solutions tailored to meet market demands and user expectations.

For the video edition, please click here.

DT 3.0: Data-Driven Design Thinking with Artificial Intelligence Tools

DT 3.0 leverages AI tools to enhance each stage, creating a more dynamic, responsive process:

  1. Determine: AI tools analyze large data sets to identify opportunities and challenges. Machine learning models predict and recommend focus areas, optimizing the identification of strategic initiatives.
  2. Discover: AI algorithms automatically analyze user behaviors and preferences, uncovering deep insights. They efficiently process and interpret vast and complex data sets, providing a richer understanding of user needs.
  3. Define: AI continuously refines problem definitions based on real-time data, dynamically adjusting to reflect market and user behavior changes. This results in more precise and timely problem statements that are closely aligned with current realities.
  4. Develop: AI assists in generating innovative solutions by simulating outcomes, predicting market trends, and suggesting optimizations based on existing data. This integration of AI provides a robust foundation for developing effective and forward-thinking solutions.
  5. Deliver: AI is used for rapid prototyping and testing, where machine learning models predict user reactions and automatically adjust designs based on real-time feedback. This accelerates the iteration cycle and enhances the relevance of the final product.
  6. Drive: AI’s predictive capabilities and automation tools continuously monitor and optimize implementation effects. Strategies are adjusted in real time to adapt to the ever-changing market conditions, ensuring that initiatives remain relevant and impactful.

Example (3): In DT 3.0, the customer journey map (See picture below) utilizes digital footprints to provide insights into online behavior. For example, by tracking online purchases of nostalgic items, you identify ‘kidults’ who seek childhood experiences. AI predicts their next likely purchases, allowing for personalized marketing campaigns. This map enhances user experience and boosts sales, showcasing a shift towards sophisticated, data-driven solutions.

Source: Samsung Digital Transformation: How to respond smartly to VUCA World

For business leaders, DT 3.0 represents an advanced stage in the evolution of design thinking. Integrating AI into this framework not only streamlines processes but also enhances decision-making, ensuring that strategies are both innovative and aligned with the latest market dynamics. This approach empowers leaders to stay ahead in rapidly evolving industries, driving sustained business growth through informed, data-driven actions.

For the video edition, please click here.

Implications for Business Leaders

The strategic impact of Design Thinking evolution on executive decision-making is significant, urging business leaders to adapt their problem-solving and innovation strategies. As Design Thinking evolves from DT 1.0 to DT 3.0, incorporating advanced data analytics and AI tools, executives can make more informed, responsive decisions that closely align with customer needs and market dynamics.

For business leaders, adopting DT 2.0 and DT 3.0 methodologies can provide a competitive advantage by enhancing the ability to understand and predict customer behaviors and enabling more precise innovation. This shift necessitates investments in technology and skills development, promoting a culture that values data literacy and continuous learning.

Additionally, the use of AI in Design Thinking allows for proactive decision-making. Leaders must manage the rapid flow of insights to make swift, informed decisions. They also need to consider the ethical use of AI to ensure solutions are equitable and transparent. In sum, the evolution of Design Thinking emphasizes strategic leadership and vision, helping leaders enhance problem-solving capabilities, improve customer engagement, and strengthen organizational resilience in a complex business environment.

For the video edition, please click here.

Reference:

Böckle, M., & Kouris, I. (2023). Design Thinking and AI : A New Frontier for Designing Human‐Centered AI Solutions. Design Management Journal, 18(1), 20-31. https://doi.org/10.1111/dmj.12085

Chung, D. (2020). Creating a memorable experience to retain valued banking customers. In Design Thinking Business CaseBook 2020 (pp. 21 to 24). Vocational Training Council (Business Discipline), Hong Kong SAR Government.

Chung, D. (2022). Creating a caring experience for passengers with special needs in the public transportation. In Design Thinking Business CaseBook 2022 (pp. 21 to 24). Vocational Training Council (Business Discipline), Hong Kong SAR Government.

Chung, D., Choi, Y., Lee, P., Lee, S., & Liu, T. (2022). Creating a memorable experience for Kwun Tong Yue Man Hawker Bazaar. In Design Thinking Business CaseBook 2022 (pp. 17 to 20). Vocational Training Council (Business Discipline), Hong Kong SAR Government.

Chung, G., & Chung, D. (2018). WOW the Hospitality Customers: Transforming Innovation into Performance Through Design Thinking and Human Performance Technology. Performance improvement (International Society for Performance Improvement), 57(2), 14-25. https://doi.org/10.1002/pfi.21772

Dash, S. K. (2023). Artificial Intelligence (AI) Facilitated Data-Driven Design Thinking. In (pp. 17-24). Springer Nature Switzerland. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-49215-0_3

Kan, S., & Chung, D. (2019). Creating the Flying Beyond passenger experience. In Design Thinking Business CaseBook 2019 (pp. 17 to 20). Vocational Training Council (Business Discipline), Hong Kong SAR Government.

Kan, S., Chung, D., & Chung, G. (2019). Customer Experience Transformation in the Aviation Industry: Business Strategy Realization through Design Thinking, Innovation Management, and HPT. Performance improvement (International Society for Performance Improvement), 58(1), 13-30. https://doi.org/10.1002/pfi.21823

Krishnan, T., Singh, A., Kumar, K., & Ganesh, J. (2022). Leverage Design Thinking to Build Enterprise AI. California Management Review Insights.

Leão, C. P., Silva, V., & Costa, S. (2024). Exploring the Intersection of Ergonomics, Design Thinking, and AI/ML in Design Innovation. Applied system innovation, 7(4), 65. https://doi.org/10.3390/asi7040065

Magistretti, S., Legnani, M., Pham, C. T. A., & Dell’Era, C. (2024). The 4S Model for AI Adoption. Research-Technology Management, 67(3), 54-63. https://doi.org/10.1080/08956308.2024.2325859

Man, I., & Chung, D. (2019). Creating Unlimited Business Opportunities for an Insurance Sales Force. In Design Thinking Business CaseBook 2019 (pp. 21 to 24). Vocational Training Council (Business Discipline), Hong Kong SAR Government.

Man, I., & Chung, D. (2019). Creating Unlimited Business Opportunities for an Insurance Sales Force Through Design Thinking. In Cases on Learning Design and Human Performance Technology (pp. 287-304). IGI Global. https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-7998-0054-5.ch015

Niehaus, M., & Mocan, M. (2024). Cultivating Design Thinking for Sustainable Business Transformation in a VUCA World: Insights from a German Case Study. Sustainability, 16(6), 2447.

Poleac, D. (2024). Design Thinking with AI. Proceedings of the International Conference on Business Excellence, 18(1), 2891-2900. https://doi.org/doi:10.2478/picbe-2024-0240

Skywark, E. R., Chen, E., & Jagannathan, V. (2022). Using the Design Thinking Process to Co-create a New, Interdisciplinary Design Thinking Course to Train 21st Century Graduate Students. Frontiers in public health, 9, 777869-777869. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2021.777869

Stackowiak, R., & Kelly, T. (2020). Design thinking in software and AI projects: proving ideas through rapid prototyping. Springer.

Staub, L., van Giffen, B., Hehn, J., & Sturm, S. (2023). Design Thinking for Artificial Intelligence: How Design Thinking Can Help Organizations to Address Common AI Project Challenges. In (pp. 251-267). Springer Nature Switzerland. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-48057-7_16

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR