English
The Role of this Technique & Tool in the Second Phase of the Design Thinking Method
In the Discover phase of Traditional Design Thinking (i.e., Design Thinking 1.0), the primary goal is to achieve a profound, empathetic understanding of users’ emotions, experiences, and expectations. This critical insight is gleaned through direct interviews, utilizing carefully crafted questions and refined skills in questioning, listening, and observing.
A statistically valid sample size for these interviews typically ranges between 30 to 60 per project. This scale is deliberate; it balances depth and manageability, allowing teams to glean approximately 300 to 600 insights. This approach ensures a deep connection with user challenges, forming the foundation for meaningful innovation.
Traditional “Empathy interviews” techniques are crucial during the Discover phase of Design Thinking. These methods allow innovation teams to explore a broad array of user needs—met, under-met, un-met, hidden, and potential needs.
Each category is key to developing a thorough understanding of user experiences, which subsequently informs the creation of more effective and innovative solutions. Let’s examine the significance of each type of need:
(1) Met Needs
Met needs are those that existing products or services have already adequately addressed, resulting in user satisfaction with the solutions available. Recognizing and understanding these needs is pivotal in the Discover stage for several reasons:
- Benchmarking: Analyzing met needs provides valuable insights into the strengths of current offerings, whether they’re from competitors or previous iterations of your solutions. This analysis helps identify successful strategies and features that resonate with users, setting a standard for quality and functionality.
- Avoiding Redundancy: By acknowledging the areas where user needs are already well-satisfied, teams can strategically allocate their resources and creativity toward more pressing issues. This prevents the unnecessary duplication of effective existing solutions, focusing innovation efforts where they can genuinely enhance value and user experience.
(2) Under-Met Needs
Under-met needs are those that current solutions address only partially, leaving users somewhat dissatisfied. Identifying and targeting under-met needs ensures that innovation efforts are directly linked to enhancing user satisfaction and closing critical gaps in the market. These needs present immediate opportunities for improvement and innovation:
- Improvement Opportunities: Highlighting under-met needs exposes the weaknesses in current offerings, providing clear directions for enhancements that could significantly boost user satisfaction and product performance.
- Prioritization: Understanding these deficiencies allows teams to prioritize development efforts, focusing on areas that will deliver the most substantial improvements in user experience and market competitiveness.
(3) Un-Met Needs
Un-met needs are gaps where no suitable solutions currently exist, presenting clear pathways for groundbreaking innovations. Focusing on unmet needs drives the creation of unique solutions that address pressing gaps, potentially transforming the market landscape:
- Innovation Triggers: Identifying un-met needs can be the catalyst for developing entirely new products or services, offering a first-mover advantage in untapped markets.
- Directing Creative Efforts: These needs guide the ideation process, focusing creative energies on solving real problems that have no existing solutions, which can lead to significant market opportunities and user benefits.
(4) Hidden Needs
Hidden needs are those that users themselves may not explicitly recognize or articulate until they are revealed through careful observation and interaction. Uncovering hidden needs allows designers to anticipate and solve problems before users become aware of them, creating a proactive innovation strategy that enhances user engagement and satisfaction:
- Competitive Edge: Solutions designed to meet hidden needs can differentiate products in a crowded market, offering features that users didn’t even know they needed but find indispensable once experienced.
- Enhancing User Experience: Addressing these needs can significantly improve the overall user experience, leading to higher satisfaction and loyalty as users feel uniquely understood and catered to.
(5) Potential Needs
Potential needs are future-oriented and may not be evident at present but are expected to emerge as user lifestyles, technology, or market conditions evolve. Identifying potential needs ensures that products not only meet the current demands but are also well-equipped to adapt to future changes, keeping the company at the forefront of innovation and market relevance:
- Future Proofing: By anticipating potential needs, organizations can develop solutions that are adaptable and flexible, ready to evolve with changing user demands and technological advancements.
- Leading the Market: Recognizing and addressing potential needs positions a company as a leader, setting trends rather than following them and establishing a reputation for innovation and forward-thinking.
The Procedure for Using This Design Thinking Tool
To effectively utilize empathy interviews for discovering the full spectrum of user demands (met, under-met, un-met, hidden, and potential), a structured and comprehensive approach is crucial. Here is a detailed procedure that integrates all the necessary steps and focuses on gathering a rich dataset – “FINDING,” which includes the critical aspects of “Feeling,” “Relevant Incident,” and “Role of the Interviewee”:
Step 1: Preparation of the interviews
- Align Project Goals: Begin by aligning the goals of the empathy interviews with the challenge statement of your innovation project. This step involves designing questions that probe into the specific challenges and areas identified in the project goals to uncover relevant user needs.
- Select Interviewees: Recruit a diverse group of major users or persons directly affected by the project, as well as major stakeholders. For this step, craft questions that cater to the unique perspectives and experiences of each group, ensuring comprehensive feedback that spans all relevant viewpoints.
- Scope User Journey: Determine the critical aspects of the user experience to explore during the interviews. Develop questions that navigate through these key interactions and touchpoints, aiming to gather detailed insights about each phase of the user journey.
Step 2: Design Interview Questions
- Craft Human-Centered Questions: Focus on creating questions that explore the user’s feelings, experiences, and needs rather than centering solely on product features or functions. This approach encourages a deeper understanding of the human aspects behind user interactions and decisions.
- Ensure Relevance: Tailor questions to align specifically with the identified aspects of the user journey and stakeholder concerns. Make sure these questions probe into the full spectrum of user demands, including met, under-met, unmet, hidden, and potential needs, to capture a comprehensive view of user experiences.
- Develop Rapport-Building Questions: Start by asking users to share personal or general aspects of their lives, establishing a comfortable rapport. Demonstrate genuine interest in their personal experiences and feelings to acknowledge their unique perspective and expertise. Finally, encourage users to narrate personal stories, which enriches the conversation with valuable context and insights, making the interaction more engaging and insightful.
Step 3: Conduct Interviews
- Prepare the Environment: Ensure the interview setting is comfortable and distraction-free to encourage open and honest dialogue. Whether in-person or virtually, the environment should foster a sense of privacy and trust.
- Use Active Listening: During the interview, practice active listening. This involves not only hearing the words the user says but also paying attention to the tone and non-verbal cues. Respond with thoughtful questions or paraphrases to demonstrate understanding and keep the conversation flowing.
- Adapt Flexibly: Be prepared to deviate from the scripted questions based on the conversation flow. This flexibility allows you to explore interesting or unexpected topics that may arise, providing deeper insights into the user’s needs and experiences.
Step 4: Documentation of Findings
- Recording and Note-Taking: Ensure detailed documentation and, if possible, record the interviews with prior consent for accuracy and thorough review later. This helps to capture verbal and non-verbal nuances that might be missed in notes alone.
- Capture Emotional Responses and Relevant Incidents: Document both the emotional responses and specific incidents described by the user, including the context, actions taken, and outcomes. This approach provides deeper insights into the user’s experiences and reactions to the product.
- Understand the Interviewee’s Role: Note the user’s specific role and responsibilities related to the product usage. This information is vital for identifying their unique needs and preferences, which can guide product improvements and customization.
The Worksheet of This Tool
Remark:
In addition to the basic explanations and A4-resolution images provided by this website, InnoEdge’s Design Thinking and Innovation Management Tools series also includes A0-size high-resolution posters, digital worksheets that support simultaneous collaboration among multiple users, and an advanced version with integrated artificial intelligence-assisted analysis features.
These professional-level tools are designed to thoroughly enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of innovation management, helping business leaders maintain a significant competitive advantage in the rapidly changing business environment. If you need more detailed information, please get in touch with us or visit our official website: www.designthinking.tools.
